Your CPA says the books are not ready to file

It usually arrives as a short email in March. The books are not in a state they can work from, there will be cleanup, and it will be billed.

It reads like criticism and it is rarely meant as one. What it means is specific: the file cannot currently support a return they are willing to sign their name to. Their signature carries professional liability, and they are not going to attach it to numbers they cannot stand behind.

What they are usually looking at

Ask for the list, in writing. Almost always it contains some of these:

Accounts that do not reconcile. If the bank balance in the file does not tie to the statement, every figure built on it is unverified — including revenue and every deduction. This is first on almost every list, and it is not negotiable. If you have a difference you cannot find, there is a method for it.

A balance sheet nobody has looked at. Negative balances that should never be negative, old uncleared items, an undeposited funds account with a balance, a suspense or "ask my accountant" account full of transactions nobody categorised.

Payroll that does not tie to the filings. Wages in the books have to agree with what was reported on the quarterly returns. Where they do not, someone has to work out which is right before anything else can happen.

Owner and personal transactions mixed in. Every one has to be identified and moved, and only you can say which is which — which is why it becomes a long email thread rather than something they can just fix.

Loans and equipment posted wrong. A financed truck recorded as an expense rather than an asset and a liability, or loan payments expensed in full rather than split between interest and principal. Common and consequential.

Missing documentation for anything that needs support.

Why the bill is what it is

This is the part worth understanding, because it changes what you do about it.

A CPA's hourly rate reflects tax expertise, professional liability and a licence. Bookkeeping cleanup does not require any of those, but when it lands on their desk in March, it gets done by their staff and billed at their firm's rates, in their busiest eight weeks of the year.

Most contractors who feel their accountant is expensive are not paying for tax work. They are paying professional rates for data entry and reconciliation that could have been done monthly at a fraction of the cost — and, crucially, done by someone whose job it was, rather than squeezed into filing season.

The way to reduce a CPA bill is almost never to negotiate the rate. It is to stop sending them a year of unreconciled transactions.

What to do this month

1. Get the list in writing, with the items ranked by what actually blocks filing.
2. Ask what is blocking versus what is tidying. Some of it stops the return; some of it is housekeeping that can wait. You need to know which is which if the deadline is close.
3. Ask whether they want to do the cleanup or would rather not. Many firms would genuinely prefer not to — it is low-margin work that clogs their busiest period — and will say so if asked directly.
4. File an extension if the timing is tight. Rushed cleanup produces a return that gets amended, which costs more than the extension.
5. Fix the cause, not just this year. If nothing changes, you will get the same email next March with a bigger number attached.

The question worth asking yourself

If your CPA is doing the bookkeeping cleanup every year, you are already paying for monthly bookkeeping. You are just paying for it once a year, at the highest available rate, at the worst possible time, and getting no management information out of it in between.

The same money spent on monthly close buys you the cleanup and a P&L you can actually use in June, when there is still time to do something about what it says.

That is the whole argument, and it is arithmetic rather than salesmanship.

Related

• What your CPA needs from you at year end
• Bookkeeper or accountant: which one do you actually need
• QuickBooks does not match your bank